Omkara

29 07 2006

Omkara: ***
omkara.jpg

I have never read any Shakespeare, and whatever little criminally abridged pieces that had found their way into my school’s English curriculum, have been forgotten. Yes you can read that last sentence again, gape out loud, widen your eyes and fall from your chair. But today, after watching Omkara, it really will be the second time in my life that I felt smug for missing out on a body of work that’s considered universally to be the “ultimate” in drama and literature. (the first time being, if you still are as dimwit to not guess, when I had watched Maqbool 2 years back). Just as the end-credits started to roll, I just couldn’t get this thought out of my head that if I had known the climax way before, I just wouldn’t have bothered with even writing this review. The number of freewheeling shockers jam-packed in the final ten minutes of the movie just wouldn’t have had that impact that (I am so thankful to my ignorance) they had.

But mincing no words now, I have to admit that I was disappointed with Omkara. With a plot pregnant with far far more drama than Maqbool, it simply didn’t have the intensity or the power of the latter. Save for the last ten minutes, when the rein from the bland characters finally passes on to the actual plot which helps it end on an above-average note, the film’s got mediocre written all over it. And that’s not because it settles for anything mediocre but because it always somehow manages to mix something superb with something very ghastly, and the bar, as a consequence, ends up raising only halfway.

Much of the damage for me came from the actors. In a tale that pivots on the central love story, sparks simply fail to fly even when the camera longedly follows Dolly (Kareena’s character) running after Omkara (Devgan) in that supposed-to-be-cutey-and-teasy scene or even when Devgan is furiously necking and pecking the Kapoor lass beneath the covers. When one has a storyline with beaten to death sequences of running away with one’s lover much to one’s family’s disdain, its upto the actors to rise above the banal and deliver. While Devgan does try valiantly to look lovestruck with his beady eyes, Kareena’s just so awfully controlled and held-back, she ends up looking quite uncomfortable and out-of-place. This when really all she had to do was little more than what she did in Refugee–do the simpleton act with a dash of charm.
Both the actors pitch in awfully calculative performances, consistently oblivious to their respective characters’ spirits, and because you are never quite convinced of the characters they are playing and their feelings for each other, right from the onset you care way too less than you should about the aftermath of Omkara’s henchman plotting against his cohort using Omkara’s love as a mere tool. Still, surprisingly enough, somehow both of these performers somehow get their act together in the scene that mattered–the climax. Its about 120 minutes too late to feel for them, but the director’s really given his all to those final fifteen minutes and ends up being successful in squeezing some sympathy from cynical watchers like me for the unpredictable and shockingly brutal end to Omkara’s love story.

It must also be said that there actually are a few things which rival the boredom of watching a whole episode of Bhabhi on Star Plus. One of those is watching Bipasha Basu do a whole 7 minute jhatak-matak dance routine. And to actually survive through two such full-length songs where we have to bear her giving the whole set of adayein complete with nain-matakka from her squint is really so bad, its funny. The girl, with due respect to her miniscule acting talent, is blatantly miscast here and absolutely thanda as the UP nautch girl Billo.

Saving the day from the aforementioned three performers are the next three lead performers who bring in some credibility to the whole set-up. Konkona Sen Sharma is totally identifiable and just downright adorable as Devgan’s sister, Indu. Right from her dialect to her lived-in maternal affection for everyone around her, she’s just right. Not a single wrong note here or there, she really brings a broad smile everytime she holds the chin of the distressed characters around her and utters “hansi badi mehengi ho gayi hai aaj kal” . Thankfully, as the second half draws to a close, her character’s scope becomes bigger and bigger until the spotlight shines solely on her and Konkona’s all too glad to oblige us with some well-felt theatrics. This is the stuff real performances are made of and I am so glad that even in the company of mainstream heavyweights, Konkona’s given enough screentime to leave a lasting impression.

And then there’s Saif, who’s surprisingly convincing as Langda Tyagi. From his hilarious, expletive-filled opening sequence to the slimier-by-every-successive minute routine where he’s supposed to bitch and plot and bitch and plot and bitch some more of how Dolly’s dating Kesu Firangi, how Kesu Firangi gifted the bejeweled waistband from Omkara’s heirloom to Billo and so on and so forth, Saif pulls it off with laudable ease. Though you have seen it all in the form of Pallavis and Mandiras in saas-bahu serials, still its reasonably entertaining watching this despicable character use reverse psychology and perfect timing of letting the wrong people hear the right thing in the wrong way to his own advantage. The havoc that just this one character creates would have carried far more punch if, as I said before, I was affected by how deeply the two protagonists (Omkara and Dolly) were affected. Instead, its the collateral damage on Kesu’s and Billo’s relationship thanks to Langda again that is far more sincere even with one tenth the screentime that Vivek Oberoi [consistently enthusiastic] gets with Bipasha.

The trend of mixing something worth lauding with something worth moaning about continues behind the camera as well. While placing a Shakespeare play in the heart of small-time crook infested UP has been done as deftly as one would expect of Mr Bhardwaj (quite unlike others, being a UPite from birth, all those dialects, jokes and expletives really hit home with me), the fact that the politics and action sit very clumsily in the screenplay (atleast to me, the magnitude of Omkara’s strengths and power came across as very vague and rushed), the central love story doesn’t have its moments and things really never warm up in the first half, it does take away a lot.

While the decidedly fresh and earthy soundtrack had gems like “Namak Ishq Ka”, “O Saathi Re”, “Sabse Bade Ladaiya Re” and “Naina Thag Lenge” which literally smelt of a remote Uttar Pradesh kasba (for want of better expression) right from their sound to their lyrics, the fact that my favourite, “Naina Thag Lenge” is used way too carelessly in the movie (as a background score to Kareena’s courtship with Devgan five minutes into the movie and it doesn’t work as the mournful suggestions of suspicion and mistrust are way too early and uncalled for) and that two full-length dance routines have the most bland picturisation ever (thanks to Ms Basu), I hold a gripe here as well.

Even the cinematographer is up playing tricks with the viewer feeding our eyes with reels on reels of unstimulating imagery until the climax *SPOILER ALERT* when a lone camera capturing a newly wed bride swinging dead above the dead groom on the floor has a shock value that’s way higher on the Richter scale than the whole film combined.

To sum it all, I haven’t lost faith in the film-making skill of Vishal Bharadwaj and I sincerely hope he continues to adapt more Shakespeare plays, but doesn’t miscast the way he has with Omkara. Yes, there are emotions running the entire length of the movie, but they are nowhere quite as deep as they should have been. There’s this nagging unshruggable feeling that something really is amiss this time around and surprisingly enough its got nothing to do with the excellent plot.

Still, the film’s worth a watch once for its intricate storyline (a rarity in our films nowadays), for watching Saif and Konkona perform and for a genuinely good climactic half an hour.


Actions

Information

22 responses to “Omkara”

31 07 2006
nokjhok » Bollywood » Movie Review : Omkara (03:40:57) :

[...] Karan probably has the first negative take on this movie in the blogosphere, and felt disappointed, and rates is just about average: But mincing no words now, I have to admit that I was disappointed with Omkara. With a plot pregnant with far far more drama than Maqbool, it simply didn’t have the intensity or the power of the latter. Save for the last ten minutes, when the rein from the bland characters finally passes on to the actual plot that it ends on an above-average note, the film’s got mediocre written all over it. [...]

31 07 2006
sonia (05:24:39) :

I really feel langra tyagi has steal the show.
gr8 work done by saif. un expected.
he may grab best villian award this time.

vishal is in the race of some serious director making good movies. we can compare him to sanjjay leela bhansali.

31 07 2006
seema gupta (19:17:01) :

I feel so good that finally the indian film industry is coming of age. The scene stealer here is Vishal Bhardwaj. The melodies are hauntingly beautiful, and the film itself par excellence. The only actor who disappoints is Bipasha Basu. She performed her scenes half-assedly, and did not do justice to two perfectly composed songs. Not to be missed film!!!! Excellent Job to the creators

31 07 2006
jEDI (21:16:34) :

I agree with Seema above. Indian film industry is starting to come of age, the standards have been raised and so naturally have our expectations :)

I think Vishal Bhardwaj thought Shakespeare shouldnt be confined to students of English literature, drama so on. Perhaps, it time to bore the unsuspecting common folk in India to death too! Seriously, Shakespeare?! Give me a break.

But as you say there are ‘moments ‘ in it and its not the usual film so I guess I’ll go ahead and watch if given the opportunity. At least for the music anyway (not that I’m hugely impressed with that either :P )

jedi

1 08 2006
Suyog (12:34:16) :

I disagree. I thought the movie was brilliant.

2 08 2006
karana23 (12:12:58) :

Sonia: Yes, there are no two ways to say it: Saif was phenomenal in the movie.

Seema: Yea, agree on your take on Bipasha’s performance. Though I personally thought she was fine in all the dialoguebaazi she did. Its just that, tolerating her on-screen for a good 10 minutes when she’s trying to shake a leg is quite an eyesore.

Jedi: Absolutely man, do watch the movie. Its definitely superior to the routine stuff playing in cinemas, but as I said, its not all that brilliant its made out to be.

Suyog: I guess its a case of different blokes, different strokes. Hehe… yea, not many people share my take on the movie, but its just a humble op :) Thanks for the nokjhok pingback though!

Thanks a lot guys for all the feedback.

Cheers!

Karan

3 08 2006
Swathi (03:45:54) :

Karan (of the Mouthshut fame I guess :)

bingo! u said it - there was absolutely no chemistry between Kareena and Ajay Devgan and since i knew the denouement beforehand, even the suspense element wasn’t there but I thought the setting was quite good and different (I mean aren’t we fed up of watching huge mansions both in the saas-bahu series as well as Karan Johar movies!!)

7 08 2006
Amrita Menon (07:16:26) :

I have also seen Omkara and really enjoyed a lot. Vishal Bharadwaj has attempted an encore with Omkara after the success of his earlier adaptation of Shakespeare’s Macbeth as Maqbool. And by all accounts he seems to have succeeded yet again. Based on the bard’s Othello Omkara is set in mofussil UP with Ajay Devgan, Kareena, Saif Ali Khan and Vivek Oberoi essay the main roles. Inam ul Rehman, a regular critic on merinews has reviewed the movie exhaustively.…..

8 08 2006
Namrata (13:33:46) :

Finally an honest review which doesn’t commend yet another non-performance by Kareena Kapoor, unlike the other reviewers and “critics” on the net.
Hopefully, I’ll catch the movie soon.
Namrata

10 08 2006
Smita Singh (04:55:05) :

karan is talking through his ass. If this is unstimulating cinematography. I wonder what stimulating is. A lack of aesthetics? Or understanding of the craft?

12 08 2006
karana23 (03:03:18) :

Thanks a lot guys for all the feedback!

Swathi: Glad we share the opinion on the chemistry bit. Yes, the rural set-up was quite interesting. Do come here often!

Amrita: Each to his own. I am glad you enjoyed it so thoroughly.

*Namrata: Hehe… no offence against Ms Kapoor but yea she could have been so much more endearing if she was just a little less calculative.

*Smita: What’s with the profanity lady? its just an opinion. Chill!

Cheers!

Karan.

12 08 2006
farhan (06:12:05) :

Mr Karan. Probably one of those guys who does not understand subtle stuff. Maybe the camera should have just flown out of the window or done a 360 degree steadicam.

12 08 2006
Rohit99 (06:36:37) :

I must say that I will have to agree with the review by Karan. At the outset I must say that the movie definitely worth watching compared to all the junk out there. I so wanted to ‘LOVE’ the movie based on all the hype. BUT I was left with the feeling at the end ‘Is this it?’ The material and the settings were so rich that the movie could have been taken to the next level. The photography was amazing in certain shots but needed to be more expansive. At times the movie moved much slower than it should have. The opening sequence was rather boring. The songs came up rather abruptly in the movie. Konkana Sen blew everyone out of the water. Noone else could match her brilliance. Kareena was the weak link. Bipasha looked amazing. Her costumes for the item numbers needed to be more earthy. I have no problems with use of foul language but at times it did not flow and seemed artificial. The chemistry between actors was lacking at times. The movie at no point draws the audience in except for the ending. I know I am being rather critical. But that is the difference between a good movie and a great one. Overall the movie lacked finish. Ending on a positive note, the music (listened to outside the context of the movie) is amazing, far superior to the movie itself. I cant stop listening to ‘O saathi Re’

12 08 2006
Rohit99 (06:40:13) :

Karan, I must say that I will have to agree with you. At the outset I must say that the movie definitely worth watching compared to all the junk out there. I so wanted to ‘LOVE’ the movie based on all the hype. BUT I was left with the feeling at the end ‘Is this it?’ The material and the settings were so rich that the movie could have been taken to the next level. The photography was amazing in certain shots but needed to be more expansive. At times the movie moved much slower than it should have. The opening sequence was rather boring. The songs came up rather abruptly in the movie. Konkana Sen blew everyone out of the water. No one else could match her brilliance. Kareena was just OK. Bipasha looked amazing, though her costumes for the item numbers needed to be more earthy. I have no problems with use of foul language but at times it did not flow and seemed artificial. The chemistry between actors was lacking at times. The movie at no point draws the audience in except for the ending. I know I am being rather critical. But that is the difference between a good movie and a great one. Overall the movie lacked finish. Ending on a positive note, the music (listened to outside the context of the movie) is amazing, far superior to the movie itself. I cant stop listening to ‘O saathi Re’

12 08 2006
shyamali (22:26:44) :

Boring opening? Expansive photography? You thought the most expansive and well composed shot to be boring?

13 08 2006
Rohit99 (22:56:57) :

Sorry, those are my opinions. You may feel differently.

21 08 2006
madhur dogra (14:04:15) :

I knoe karenna is natural beauty and it works

Good luck

31 08 2006
mom (06:56:31) :

Hi Sun!!

Well!!!i have to agree here..that the movie is worth watching once.Though at times the abusive language somtimes gets on ur nerves!!!(wish they cud do without it!)_ The ones who really steal the show are Konkana and Saif.Remarkable performance i must say!!!The rest were just average..An accomplished actor like Naseerudin Shah esp.was really unimpressive.
Bipasha too needs to tone down as a village belly…she looked as stunning as she was in ‘No Entry’doin the dance number Ishq di Gali wich kar Entry’.
The song O Saathi Re’ws really worth listening to.

Lv n God Bless!!

31 08 2006
karana23 (15:03:26) :

Hey Mom!

Yup, the movie is worth a watch once. And yes, the film does have a nice soundtrack!

Great to have you commenting so often!

Keep them coming!

Cheers!

1 09 2006
Mad Munky (13:10:49) :

Interesting review :) I haven’t seen the film - probably won’t see it for some time. I’m more interested in the music - my favourite is also ‘Naina thag lenge’. I was curious to see how it would be used in the film - bit disappointing that they stuck it at the start. :)

27 10 2006
terri (14:12:34) :

the most beautiful pic ever i love the song beedi chunariya & namakishq ka see it .enjoy.!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

25 02 2007
alcohol can drink i taking while zithromax (10:34:39) :

alcohol can drink i taking while zithromax

news

Leave a comment

You can use these tags : <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>